¿The false North Korean mantras? Denuclearization, collapse of the regime and reunification

Authors

  • Xavier Boltaina Bosch Universidad de Barcelona

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.14422/cir.i09.y2017.002

Keywords:

North Korea, DPRK, reunification, denuclearization, collapse, Kim Jong-un

Abstract

This article analyses three issues that most analysts and researches have studied in their published documents and monographs: North Korea’s denuclearization, the future of the regime and a hypothetical reunification. In contrast to almost all documents mentioned, the author argues that North Korea’s nuclear programme is unstoppable; in fact, its interruption would probably entail a huge risk for the survival of the North Korean system, given that it constitutes a key element of its national and military security strategy. Similarly, the collapse of the regime has been anticipated since 1990 but it has not yet been materialized during the last 25 years. In this document, the author explains the reasons for the improbability of the regime’s collapse and, what is more, the consolidation of the third member of the Kim family. Finally, the document is sceptic concerning the analyses that predict that North Korea’s future will inevitably entail a reunification with the South, and the article argues that the survival of North Korea is likely; the country could evolve in many ways, but never through an absorption by the South. Therefore, this article attempts to contextualize and rebate the three mantras mentioned in its title: that North Korea must give up its nuclear program, that the regime will eventually collapse and, that, as a natural process, the North will be reunified with the South, eventuating in the latter being declared as a victor.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Xavier Boltaina Bosch, Universidad de Barcelona

Profesor de la Facultad de Derecho, Universidad de Barcelona
Gerente y Profesor de la Universidad Internacional Menéndez y Pelayo- sede de Cataluña
Secretario del Centro Español de Investigaciones Coreanas (Universidad de Castilla La Mancha)

References

Beal, T. (2006). It’s time to stop trying to predict North Korea’s collapse. NK News. Recuperado de www.nk.news.org.

Bennet, B. W. (2013). Preparing for the possibility of North Korean collapse. RAND Corporation. Recuperado de http://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/research_reports/RR300/RR331/RAND_RR331.pdf

Boltaina, X. (2014, 10 de febrero). Diciembre rojo en Corea del Norte: diez puntos clave y diez conclusiones sobre la ejecución del general Jang Song-thae. Documento marco num.3/2014, Instituto Español de Estudios Estratégicos-Ministerio de Defensa. Recuperado de http://www.ieee.es/Galerias/fichero/docs_marco/2014/DIEEEM03-2014_CoreaNorte_DiciembreRojo_BoltainaBosch.pdf

Bracken, P. (1993). Nuclear weapons and State in North Korea. Survival 35(3), 137-153.

Bracken, P. (2017). Fire in the East. En Petrovic, M., La Marcha atrás nuclear. El País.

Cao de Benós, A. (2013). Alma Roja, sangre azul. Editorial Base Hispánica.

Cavazos, R. (2012, 26 de junio). Mind the Gap between rhetoric and reality. Nautilius Institute. Recuperado de http://nautilus.org/napsnet/napsnet-special-reports/mind-the-gapbetween-rhetoric-and-reality/

Collins, R. (2016). Pyongyang Republic. HRNK. Committee for Human Rights in North Korea. Washington. Recuperado de https://www.hrnk.org/uploads/pdfs/Collins_PyongyangRepublic_FINAL_WEB.pdf

Deane, M. J. (s.f.). The collapse of North Korea: a prospect to celebrate or fear. John Hopkins University. Recuperado de http://www.jhuapl.edu/ourwork/nsa/papers/NorthKorea.pdf

Delisle, G. (2013). Pyongyang. Editorial Astiberri.

Fifield, A. (2016, 8 de mayo). North Korea announces five-year economic plan, its first since the 1980s. The Washington Post.

Frank, R. (2016). The Unification cases of Germany and Korea: a dangerous comparison. USKorea Institute at SAIS. Recuperado de: http://38north.org/2016/12/rfrank120816/ (primera parte); y http://38north.org/2016/11/rfrank110316/ (segunda parte).

Gause, K. (2015). North Korean House of Cards: leadership dynamics under Kim Jong-un. HRNK. Recuperado de https://www.hrnk.org/uploads/pdfs/HRNK_Gause_NKHOC_FINAL.pdf

Halberstam, D. (2007). The coldest winter: America and the Korean War. Hachette books.

Halberstam, D. (2008). La guerra olvidada: historia de la guerra de Corea. Editorial Crítica.

Harden, B. (2014). Evasión del campo 14. Editorial Kailas.

Kim, R. E. (2014). Los mártires de Pyongyang. Editorial Sajalin.

Kim, S. (2015). Sin ti no hay nosotros. Ediciones Blackie.

Kim, Y. & Jung, T. (2016). Status of Social Economy development in Seoul. A case study of Seoul. GSEF Social Economy Policy Guidebook. Recuperado de http://neweconomy.net/sites/default/files/status%20of%20social%20economy%20development%20in%20seoul.pdf

Lee, E. (2011). El mundo es más grande ahora: mi cautiverio en Corea del Norte. Editorial Rialp.

Lee, H. (2015). La chica de los siete nombres: la historia de una huida de Corea del Norte. Ediciones Península.

Mateos, R. (2008). El país del presidente eterno: crónica de un viaje a Corea del Norte. Editorial Milenio.

Morillot, J. & Malovic, D. (2016). La Corée du Nord en 100 questions. París: Tallandier.

Nurnus, M. & Van Beek, M. A. (2017). North Korea in the European press: an analysis of stereotypes in British, French and German newspapers. Yonsei Journal of International Studies.

O’Carroll, C. (2014). How long until North Korea collapses? Eleven defector perspectives. NK News. Recuperado de www.nk.news.org.

Office of the Secretary of Defense. (2015). Military and security developments involving the DPR of Korea. Annual Report to Congress. Recuperado de https://www.defense.gov/Portals/1/Documents/pubs/Military_and_Security_Developments_Involving_the_Democratic_Peoples_Republic_of_Korea_2015.PDF

Park. Y. (2017). Escapar para vivir: el viaje de una joven norcoreana hacia la libertad. Editorial Plataforma.

Petrovic, M. (2017, 21 de mayo). La Marcha atrás nuclear. El País.

Pitarch, B. (2012). Cerrado 24 horas: crónica de un viaje a Corea del Norte. Editorial Leartes.

Rees, L. (2009). El holocausto asiático: los crímenes japoneses en la segunda guerra mundial. Editorial Crítica.

Stares, P.B. & Wit, J.S. (2009, enero). Preparing for Sudden Change in North Korea. Council Special Report, nr. 42.

Toman, O. (2016, 30 de noviembre). North Korea’s byungjinline will succeed. NK News. Recuperado de www.nk.news.org.

Triplett, W. C. (2004). Rogue State: How a nuclear North Korea threatens America. Regnery Publ.

Wizenberg, D. & Varsavsky, J. (2016). Dos caras de una misma Corea. Ediciones Clave intelectual.

Yang, C. S. (2016). Why German Unification is not a model for Korean unification. US-Korea Institute at SAIS. Recuperado de http://38north.org/2016/05/cyang052516/

How to Cite

Boltaina Bosch, X. (2017). ¿The false North Korean mantras? Denuclearization, collapse of the regime and reunification. Comillas Journal of International Relations, (9), 19–45. https://doi.org/10.14422/cir.i09.y2017.002