Judicial Ethics: the paradigm of good Judge

Authors

  • Ignacio Sancho Gargallo Audiencia Provincial de Barcelona

Keywords:

Ethics for justices, judicial deontology, a good Judge, independence, impartiality, integrity, prudence, love of learning, responsibility and spirit of service

Abstract

In order to identify good ethical practices for justices/judges we may considerwhat constitutes a role model judge (“Good Judge”). First, it is necessary to point out that it is not only a matter of normative; we can’t reduce ethics for justices to alist of duties and rights. A “good judge” must also be someone who develops professionally the necessary virtues required in order to perform his or her function well (judicial virtues). A “good Judge” is independent and impartial carrying out his function, and judge with prudence (according with the facts and the Law). He or she has social conscience and ongoing commitment to furthering his or her knowledge. A Good Judge is held in high esteem by the lawyers and people who work under him orher, and is aware not only about the dignity of his Job but also that he or she has toserve to the society with the spirit of sacrifice.

Author Biography

Ignacio Sancho Gargallo, Audiencia Provincial de Barcelona

Doctor en DerechoPresidente de la sección 15 (Mercantil)

References

APARICI MILLARES y LOPEZ GUZMÁN, Concepto y fundamento de la Deontología, en AAVV, Ética de las profesiones jurídicas, Madrid 2003, pág. 75.

ARISTÓTELES, Ética a Nicómaco, Libro 1-13, y Libro II-1, Centro de Estudios Políticos y Constitucionales, Madrid 2002

ATIENZA, Virtudes judiciales, Claves de razón práctica nº 86

Código Modelo de Ética Judicial aprobado en la Cumbre Iberoamericana de Justicia en junio de 2006

D’ORS, en “Una introducción al estudio del Derecho”, Madrid 1963

ENGISCH, “La idea de concreción en el Derecho y en la ciencia jurídica actuales”, Pamplona 1968

ENTRENA KLETT, en La equidad y el arte de juzgar, 1990

GABALDON, Reflexiones sobre la ética judicial, en AAVV, Ética de las profesiones jurídicas, Madrid 2003

MACCORMICK, Legal Reasoning and Legal Theory, 1987

MACINTYRE, Tras la virtud, 1987

NUSSBAUM, Justicia poética, Barcelona, 1997

POLO, Etica, Madrid, 1997

RECASENS SICHES, Introducción al estudio del derecho, México, 1970.

The Bangalore Principles of Judicial Conduct, elaborados por en el segundo encuentro de “The Judicial Group on Strengthening Judicial Integrity”, celebrado en 2001 en Bangalore (India), en anexo ECOSOC 2006/23.

Published

2012-11-15

How to Cite

Sancho Gargallo, I. (2012). Judicial Ethics: the paradigm of good Judge. Icade. Journal of the Faculty of Law at Universidad Pontificia Comillas, (72), 117–138. Retrieved from https://revistas.comillas.edu/index.php/revistaicade/article/view/410